Buying property in the Riviera Maya is an exciting journey. You find the perfect spot in Playa del Carmen, Tulum, or Mérida. You complete the purchase. You finally get the keys to your dream home. Then, you find a problem.

Maybe you see a persistent leak in the ceiling. Perhaps you notice a long crack forming in a wall. Or maybe the plumbing system just does not work correctly.

Discovering a serious flaw after you buy is a nightmare for any homeowner. In Mexico, these issues are known as vicios ocultos, or hidden defects.

Fortunately, Mexican law provides protections for buyers in this situation. However, the legal paths are complex and, most importantly, very time-sensitive. Understanding your rights is the first step. Acting quickly is the second.

---

What Exactly Is a “Hidden Defect” in Mexico?

The law does not cover every minor imperfection. A true vicio oculto under the Mexican Civil Code is a specific type of problem. To qualify, the defect must meet three main conditions.

First, the defect must not be apparent at the time of purchase. This means a normal, reasonable inspection by a non-expert would not have discovered it. A large, obvious crack in the foundation that you simply missed may not qualify. A faulty pipe sealed inside a wall, however, almost certainly would.

Second, the defect must have existed before the sale. The problem must originate from the construction or materials, even if it only became visible months later. For example, a bad foundation that only shows cracks after the first rainy season would qualify.

Third, the defect must be serious. This is a key legal test. The problem must be significant enough to make the property unfit for its intended use. Or, the defect must diminish the property’s value so much that you would have paid a considerably lower price (or not bought it at all) if you had known about it.

In most cases, the seller or developer is legally responsible for these hidden defects. This is true even if they claim they did not know about the problem.

---

Your Rights Under the Civil Code: The 6-Month Ticking Clock

If your property has a genuine hidden defect, the Civil Code (which governs private sales) gives you two main options. These legal paths are called acciones edilicias.

1. The “I Want Out” Option (Acción Redhibitoria) This action allows you to rescind (annul) the entire sales contract. You would return the defective property to the seller. In return, the seller must give you a full refund of the purchase price, plus any expenses you paid during the contract.
2. The “Price Cut” Option (Acción Quanti Minoris) This action allows you to keep the property. However, you can demand a reduction in the purchase price. An expert appraiser typically determines this price cut. The amount should be proportional to the defect’s impact on the property’s value.

Here is the most critical part: you must act extremely fast.

The statute of limitations for these Civil Code claims is notoriously short. In most cases, you have only six months from the date the property was delivered to file your claim. If you wait, you could lose these rights completely. This short deadline is one of the biggest pitfalls for foreign buyers who discover problems.

---

Developer Warranties: A Different Set of Rules

This 6-month rule often causes confusion. Many buyers ask, “Only six months? What about a warranty?”

This is where the law gets complex. The 6-month deadline applies to the vicios ocultos remedies in the Civil Code. However, if you bought a new property from a developer, you likely have a different, stronger set of protections.

These protections come from Mexico’s Federal Consumer Protection Law (LFPC). This law mandates that developers must provide guarantees for new construction. These warranties are much longer than the Civil Code’s 6-month window:

• Five years for structural issues (like foundations, walls, and load-bearing elements).
• Three years for waterproofing (roofs, seals, etc.).
• One year (minimum) for other elements (like fixtures, fittings, and finishes).

These consumer protection laws provide different remedies. They may include repair of the defect, replacement of the property, or even rescission of the contract. This creates a separate legal path for holding a developer accountable. Therefore, your strategy depends heavily on who you bought from (a private seller vs. a developer) and the nature of the defect.

---

How to Protect Yourself from Hidden Defects in Riviera Maya Real Estate

The best strategy is always prevention. However, if you do find a problem, you must take immediate and decisive action.

Before You Buy: Prevention

The single best way to protect yourself is to get a professional inspection. Hire a qualified, independent architect or engineer before you close the deal. They can spot red flags that you would never see. Furthermore, you should have an experienced lawyer review your purchase contract. Your lawyer can ensure the developer’s warranty clauses are clear, fair, and fully compliant with the law.

After You Buy: Taking Action

If you discover a potential hidden defect, do not wait.

1. Document Everything: Take clear photos and videos of the problem. Write down a timeline of when you first noticed it.
2. Get an Expert Opinion: Hire a professional architect or contractor to inspect the defect. You need a written report that explains the problem, its likely cause, and the cost to fix it.
3. Contact Your Lawyer Immediately: This is the most important step. Because the legal deadlines are so strict, you must get professional advice right away.

An experienced real estate lawyer can analyze your situation. They will determine if your case falls under the 6-month Civil Code rule or the longer developer warranties from the LFPC. This will define the entire legal strategy to fix the problem and protect your investment.

---

Facing a hidden defect dispute in the Riviera Maya? Don’t navigate it alone. Contact PeninsuLawyers to protect your investment and secure your property rights.